Table of Contents
As an online liquidation service, we fill our inventory through different sources. The most common are through overstocks and customer returns.
But which offers better value—overstock or customer returns? Let’s settle this debate once and for all.
What Are Overstock and Customer Return Items?
Overstock items arrive at our warehouse in pristine condition—brand new, never touched by consumers. These products exist because retailers ordered too much inventory, discontinued certain lines, or needed to clear seasonal merchandise. Think of the 65″ smart TV that didn’t sell during Black Friday or the patio furniture still in stock when fall arrived. Retailers can’t keep these items indefinitely, so they sell them to liquidators like us at steep discounts.
Customer returns are different. When shoppers change their minds or discover issues with products, these items flow back to retailers. Some returns remain sealed in original packaging; others show signs of use or require minor repairs. A returned blender might work perfectly but have a scratched base. A furniture set might be missing assembly instructions but contain all parts.
Both categories represent extraordinary value—but for different buyers with different needs.
The Pros and Cons: Overstock vs. Customer Returns
We’ve handled thousands of pallets of both types, giving us unique insight into their respective advantages:
Overstock Strengths:
- Factory-sealed, brand-new condition
- Original warranty often still applies
- Predictable quality across entire lots
- Ready for immediate resale without testing
- Perfect for sellers who prioritize turnover speed
Overstock Limitations:
- Higher acquisition cost per item
- Lower profit margins (typically 30-50%)
- More competition from other resellers
- Less room for value-adding activities
Customer Return Strengths:
- Significantly lower acquisition costs
- Higher potential profit margins (50-200%+)
- Less competition in certain categories
- Opportunity to add value through testing/repair
Customer Return Challenges:
- Varied conditions require thorough inspection
- Some items need cleaning, repackaging, or repair
- Higher rate of unsellable merchandise (5-15%)
- More time-intensive to process and list
How Online Liquidation Auction Ensures Value and Transparency
We’ve revolutionized the liquidation industry by rejecting the “mystery box” approach. When you bid on our platform, you’ll never wonder what you’re getting.
For overstock lots, we verify factory seals, check for damage during transit, and confirm all items match the manifest. With customer returns, we go further—testing electronics, noting cosmetic issues, and categorizing items by condition. Our detailed lot descriptions include actual photos of the merchandise you’re bidding on, not stock images.
This transparency extends to our entire operation. We publish delivery timeframes (averaging just two days nationwide), clearly mark items with free shipping, and maintain an open-door policy for inspection at our warehouse facilities.
How to Bid Online and Win the Best Deals
Securing the best value requires strategy, not just luck. Here’s our insider approach to winning auctions:
- Register and browse early. New auctions appear weekly, but early birds spot the best lots before bidding heats up.
- Study the manifest carefully. We provide detailed spreadsheets for most lots. Calculate potential profit based on current market values minus your acquisition cost.
- Set firm bid limits. Decide your maximum bid before the auction starts and stick to it. Emotional bidding erodes profits.
- Consider total costs. Factor in shipping (free on select items), storage space, and processing time when determining value.
- Start small. New to liquidation? Begin with a smaller lot to learn the ropes before committing to truckload quantities.
For overstock bidders, focus on current retail demand and seasonal trends. For customer returns, evaluate your ability to test, repair, and remarket items with minor issues.
Our most successful bidders often specialize—becoming experts in particular categories like furniture liquidation sales or electronics auctions rather than chasing random deals.
Expert Tips for Maximizing Profit and Minimizing Risk
After facilitating thousands of successful auctions, we’ve identified key strategies that separate thriving resellers from struggling ones:
For overstock buyers:
- Target categories with strong everyday demand rather than trendy items
- Calculate storage costs for seasonal merchandise
- Research MAP (Minimum Advertised Price) policies that might restrict your selling prices
For customer return buyers:
- Budget 3-5 hours of processing time per pallet
- Develop relationships with repair services for items beyond your expertise
- Create a system for parts harvesting from unsalvageable items
Both categories benefit from diversified selling channels. The most successful liquidation resellers utilize multiple platforms—from Amazon and eBay to local marketplaces and brick-and-mortar outlets.
According to the National Retail Federation, retailers see an average of $890 billion in returns annually—creating an endless supply of inventory for prepared resellers. This massive market rewards those who approach it systematically.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the typical condition of customer returns? While conditions vary, our customer returns typically break down as: 60-70% like-new or working perfectly with minor cosmetic issues, 20-25% requiring minor repairs or missing non-essential components, and 5-15% suitable for parts harvesting. We clearly indicate condition expectations in each lot description.
How quickly will I receive my items after winning an auction? We pride ourselves on speed. Most auction winners receive their merchandise within 2 days of payment processing. Select items ship free, while others incur standard freight charges based on weight and destination.
Can I inspect items before bidding? Absolutely! We encourage serious bidders to schedule warehouse visits. Can’t make it in person? Our detailed photos, condition reports, and responsive customer service team provide the next best thing to being here.
Why Online Liquidation Auction Is the Smart Choice
Whether you’re drawn to the predictability of overstock or the profit potential of customer returns, we’ve built our reputation on making liquidation auctions accessible, transparent, and profitable for businesses of all sizes.
We don’t just sell liquidation merchandise—we provide the information, support, and reliability you need to build a sustainable resale business. Our weekly auctions feature fresh inventory from major retailers, delivered quickly to your door with the condition clarity that only comes from proper inspection.
Ready to discover which type of inventory works best for your business model? Register today at OLABid.com and join thousands of entrepreneurs who’ve transformed their businesses through strategic liquidation buying.
Download the app now and turn these strategies into victories. Your winning bid awaits.
